Matthew and Luke recount a healing that is surprising in several respects.
It is a foreigner, but not just any foreigner—a Roman occupier—who seeks Jesus’ help.
He asks for healing for his servant, and refuses to have the Messiah Jesus come to his home because he considers himself unworthy of such an honor.
Matthew chose to cite this extraordinary example at the risk of shocking his Jewish readership. Indeed, this soldier symbolizes the occupation of the land of Israel.
It appears that Matthew is trying to portray Jesus’ authority and influence as the Messiah, which are not confined to the Jewish people but also extend to society’s leaders, including foreigners.
The man in question is not acting out of self-interest, but solely out of compassion for his slave, which is surprising for a soldier of his standing.
Jesus did not avoid soldiers. For example, in , an officer had asked for his help to heal his son (John 4.46-54). This account by John, dating from the end of the first century, no longer raises the same questions as those that arose when Matthew was written around AD 44, according to our analysis.
What is most surprising, however, is what happens next. The officer refuses to have the Master come to his home, considering himself unworthy to receive him under his roof. Like the preceding leper, he calls Jesus "Master" and recognizes his authority over disease. Matthew paints the portrait of an exceptional man of great faith, who asks only for a word from the Messiah to command his slave’s healing.
Jesus expressed his admiration for the officer, an observation very rare in the Gospels. Luke notes this remark following his research, while Matthew simply mentions that the servant was healed immediately. Luke also adds that the officer was accompanied by other servants who confirmed the facts on the spot.
One might wonder why Matthew did not mention the Messiah Jesus’ admiration for this officer. Perhaps it was because he was a soldier, a foreigner, and an occupier, and there were no equally remarkable examples in Israel.